
Originally Posted by
erichkknaar

Originally Posted by
dzajic

Originally Posted by
erichkknaar

Originally Posted by
dzajic
Once again and again and again. It does not matter if Biden ends up having 5 million more votes than Trump in California and New York (and likewise for Trump in Texas) if Trump gets 1 single vote more in Florida, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Arizona and North Carolina each. (looking at current swing states on 538)
Though it is something that Democrats will have to face after the elections, if they are not truly just a controlled opposition. If Trump does win the election he will certainly do it without winning the (legally and functionally meaningless) popular vote. That would have the Republicans controlling the presidency for 16 years total between 2000 and 2024 while winning the popular vote only a single time.
The fundamental issue with the american political system, and how badly it represents what the people actually want.
And it is again by the design. The saintly and hallowed Founding Fathers wanted to keep the power in the hands of rich protestant landowning nobility, even when creating a democratic republic.
And it includes the method to correct this. The real issue is that it's convenient to treat the constitution like stone tablets for a lot of the political class. We could cancel the second amendment tomorrow if we really wanted to.
1. Not designed to "represent what the people want". It's designed to represent what the 50 States want. The States are the sovereign powers, which makes sense when you think that the U.S. was formed out of 13 independent colonies all looking out for themselves first and foremost.
I bet if you were a small country in a future soon-to-be-Unified-into-one-nation-EU, you'd want the same system. Not because you "hate democracy", but because each State has it's own interests and doesn't want to be left out in the cold and forgotten in a system that only serves New York, California and Texas and a few others and ignores the interests of the other 43 or so states.
2. You're 100% right, we possess, today, the mechanic to fix any and all of these issues, if we agree enough to do so. We've amended the Constitution many times, we can (and should) do so again when needed.
The challenge is agreement. And I don't think you're going to get 50 states to agree to disenfranchise 43 of them and hand all US political power to the aforementioned 5-7 States.
And yes, we could repeal the 2nd Amendment. You just need 2/3 of the House and Senate and then 3/4 of the States. So sadly, being "correct" isn't enough, you actually have to convince people you're correct.
Bookmarks